Writer Forum

Welcome to the Chillifreeze Writers forum! This forum is for Indian writers, new or seasoned, published or yet to be published, or those who just want to learn more about writing, freelancing, and editing.

This is a meeting place for writers to connect, discuss writing related issues and share ideas.

After you register at CF, you will be able to post comments, start a new discussion, reply to existing comments on the Chillifreeze forums. If you have not yet registered at Chillifreeze, please click here to sign up.

Have fun connecting with fellow writers!

Forums

Forum Home

Discussions

Ask a Question

Help with revie...

Help with reviewing a wordy article

5/14/2008 10:11:32 AM

Aju

20 posts

Help with reviewing a wordy article

I have been assigned the task of reviewing an article of my colleague. He has to send the article for publishing to a technical journal.
The article has very long paragraphs but doesn’t cover too many technical concepts. This is the second round of review and I am wondering how to make these suggestions without being overly critical.

5/16/2008 12:07:06 PM

Raghav

24 posts

Re: Help with reviewing a wordy article

As a reviewer you are an important piece of the puzzle that helps the writer polish his article.

While reviewing, its important to keep the big picture in mind. Make sure that you point out the strengths and weaknesses of the writeup and offer a balanced feedback.

Page 1 of 1